First of all let me say that I love Michigan football and I wanted Jim or John Harbaugh, Les Miles, Jon Gruden, Pat Fitzgerald and Gary Patterson before one Brady Hoke. However in listening to the feedback and vitriol over the coaching search, the phrase THIS IS MICHIGAN has made my head spin. The hiring of Brady Hoke fits perfectly with the THIS IS MICHIGAN statement.
Think for a second of what Michigan does in coaching hires. Bo Schembechler begat Gary Moeller, who begat Lloyd Carr which led to Rich Rodriguez. Big names? No. In basketball, the chain went from Johnny Orr to Bill Frieder to Steve Fisher to Brian Ellerbe to Tommy Amaker to John Beilein. What is the common theme here? With the exception of Rodriguez all of the above were not big names. Michigan does not subscribe to the hot name theory. Many thought Schembechler should have hired Bob Knight even after Fisher won the 89 title. Fans clamored for Rick Pitino, sorry never going to happen. The only time they stepped out of the big name arena was for Rodriguez and that was after Miles and Greg Sciano did not work out.
Was Hoke the best candidate? The answer is an obvious no, after all his record at Ball State and San Diego State was a mediocre 47-50. However there is no evidence that he will be either a great or poor choice. Besides the Michigan names I listed above compare the sizzle of the Hoke hire to these guys. Gene Chizik, Brett Bielema, Chip Kelly, Kirk Ferentz, and even Jim Tressel. None of these hires were popular with their fan bases and they worked out fine. Michigan has to hope that that Hoke is the steady and slow tortoise who in the long run will outlast the hares named Miles and Harbaugh. Only time will tell if their fan base will be patient enough to watch the race. If I am grading the hire I give it a B-, which fits the THIS IS MICHIGAN history.
I have no problem with being upset at the way the search has gone on. The 2011 recruiting class may be one of the worst in history. But, realize the THIS IS MICHIGAN cries turn on deaf ears because Michigan is proving that THIS IS MICHIGAN. Fans want to go back to the days of competing for Big 10 titles every year. Well they did it without big names or glitz. The more flashy programs pay big name coordinators over 700 thousand dollars, that does not happen here. THIS IS MICHIGAN, you loved it for 40 years and you may or may not love it again, but the reality is that Brady Hoke is the perfect hire for those who say BUT THIS IS MICHIGAN, because this is what has been done for nearly half of a century…THIS IS MICHIGAN