I was in the same position as you a couple months ago, and I was actually looking for an impala also, but being a college kid I went the cheapest route I could find.
95' Civic EX, 4dr, 5 speed (125 HP, power everything, moon roof, ABS, cruise, 4 wheel disc brakes ect.)
$70/month-full coverage (19 years old, all in my name)
$44 for registration for the year
around 31 MPG city/41 MPG highway
Yes, I also disliked Hondas quite a lot also.