Systemax302
Forum Member
I'd take Papelbon. I just hope the Phillies will want to unload him. In the mean time, try Smylie as the closer.
I'd gladly take Papelbon, but his contract is pretty massive for the next 3 years, I believe around 13M per. Smyly is a pretty good pitcher, but he's never really experienced many closing situations and the bigger concern is his numbers against rightys. Right handers are hitting .267 against Smyly, his 1.48 WHIP is WAY too high, 9 walks, and he's given up 7 earned runs and 23 hits to rightys. Those are not good numbers at all and the majority of MLB lineups are right handed which is why you hardly ever see a left handed closer. Given that information I don't think Smyly is a good option.