Static IP address?

Anthony

Club Member
Ok wtFf

My IP address has been the same since I moved. 5 years

I got rid of The bad Comcast modem and bought my own from Best Buy on the recommendations of Mike94ltz

That was on May, 19 since then my IP address has changed three times Comcast calls it dynamic. and Comcast tells me all residential is dynamic, commercial is static.

Was the guy being a asshole?
 
I believe you have to pay extra for a static IP address, and it has been that way for a while.
 
I don't know if it was static since 2011, but the ip didn't change in that time frame.

It changing is messing up my remote view on my security cameras


Then how do you ban people from forums? If the ip changes?

And if they change this frequently, what is the point of the ip blocker programs?
 
Yeah all residential is supposedly Dynamic, mine doesn't change very often though like maybe once a year or so? You just need a dynamic dns setup for it no biggie. Most camera systems even come with a free one now.
 
Yeah all residential is supposedly Dynamic, mine doesn't change very often though like maybe once a year or so? You just need a dynamic dns setup for it no biggie. Most camera systems even come with a free one now.

This. Some routers even have DynDNS built in, you just add your credentials and go.
 
And if they change this frequently, what is the point of the ip blocker programs?

IP blockers are used to prevent brute force attacks on a network. Brute force attacks are carried out by bots that try an x amount of various combinations of letters, numbers, and symbols in order to guess passwords and gain access to the network.
 
He was not being an asshole; he told you the truth.

When your PC (or more likely - wifi router) boots up when connected to the cable modem, it asks the Comcast network for an IP address. That process/protocol is called DHCP. When Comcast receives your router's IP request, if it's a new device on the network, Comcast assigns you an unused IP from a large pool IPs. When it does this, it also creates a 'lease' record in its database that 'router Anthony' has been assigned IP 1.2.3.4 and that lease expires in XX hours. If you then power down or disconnect your router, as long as you reconnect before the lease expires, you'll be assigned the same IP address & the lease end time will be extended another XX hours. However, if you disconnect for longer than that, or even just past the lease expiration time, that IP lease record is wiped out from the database... "your" IP gets put back into the unused pool... and 'router Anthony' will be treated just like a new device again when you reconnect.

Most of us leave our wifi router running 24x7, so this allows your router periodically & continually re-up & extend the IP lease... giving you the perception that it is static and never changes. But if you have an extended power outage, or turn the router while on a week vaca, etc... yes, the lease will expire. Different ISPs also use different lease time allocations.. some shorter, some longer.

What's I've described above is dynamic IP service, which is the default service for all ISP connections unless they tell you otherwise. In the residential space, even more so. Yes, some ISPs allow you to pay a monthly uplift charge so that you have a static IP. In reality, it's the same thing I posted above... except that instead of the lease time being a few hours, they make it a few years. There are also true static IPs, but you'll probably never have to deal with that unless you work in IT on L3 networks.

So, TLDR - Comcast nor any other ISP is going guarantee you that you get a certain IP for any amount of time, unless they also offer static IP service for an upcharge. Theoretically, from their perspective, you aren't supposed to be running servers from your residential cable modem (TOS violation)... so you shouldn't need a static IP.

Tin already gave you one workaround... sign up for a Dynamic DNS service... and when you connect to your IP cameras remotely, instead of entering the Comcast IP, you'll use a domain name like anthonyscameras.ddns.org.... and the DDNS service will track what & when your router's IP changes, etc.
 
Last edited:
He was not being an asshole; he told you the truth.

When your PC (or more likely - wifi router) boots up when connected to the cable modem, it asks the Comcast network for an IP address. That process/protocol is called DHCP. When Comcast receives your router's IP request, if it's a new device on the network, Comcast assigns you an unused IP from a large pool IPs. When it does this, it also creates a 'lease' record in its database that 'router Anthony' has been assigned IP 1.2.3.4 and that lease expires in XX hours. If you then power down or disconnect your router, as long as you reconnect before the lease expires, you'll be assigned the same IP address & the lease end time will be extended another XX hours. However, if you disconnect for longer than that, or even just past the lease expiration time, that IP lease record is wiped out from the database... "your" IP gets put back into the unused pool... and 'router Anthony' will be treated just like a new device again when you reconnect.

Most of us leave our wifi router running 24x7, so this allows your router periodically & continually re-up & extend the IP lease... giving you the perception that it is static and never changes. But if you have an extended power outage, or turn the router while on a week vaca, etc... yes, the lease will expire. Different ISPs also use different lease time allocations.. some shorter, some longer.

What's I've described above is dynamic IP service, which is the default service for all ISP connections unless they tell you otherwise. In the residential space, even more so. Yes, some ISPs allow you to pay a monthly uplift charge so that you have a static IP. In reality, it's the same thing I posted above... except that instead of the lease time being a few hours, they make it a few years. There are also true static IPs, but you'll probably never have to deal with that unless you work in IT on L3 networks.

So, TLDR - Comcast nor any other ISP is going guarantee you that you get a certain IP for any amount of time, unless they also offer static IP service for an upcharge. Theoretically, from their perspective, you aren't supposed to be running servers from your residential cable modem (TOS violation)... so you shouldn't need a static IP.

Tin already gave you one workaround... sign up for a Dynamic DNS service... and when you connect to your IP cameras remotely, instead of entering the Comcast IP, you'll use a domain name like anthonyscameras.ddns.org.... and the DDNS service will track what & when your router's IP changes, etc.

Who said anyone was being as asshole?

I'm just asking questions here
 
Oh, no. That guy was being a asshole.

I thought you meant I called darko or someone responding here a asshole. Because I was asking about ip blockers.

My bad

FYI

Every Comcast xfinity employee is an asshole. :-D
 
So our router or gateway will always have the same ip correct? I always use the same ip to log into them.

It's just the external (public) IP address that changes?
 
Most also lack the networking skills to assist...

Sent from my XT1254 using Tapatalk 2

yes, because if they were highly trained network/ IT techs, they would have to pay them much more. The ISPs simply provide you with an internet connection. Configuration of customer equipment is the customers responsibility. (Do it themselves, or pay an IT guy)
 
FYI

Every Comcast xfinity employee is an asshole. :-D


I don't view them all as assholes. Most are just good people working for the devil :lol:

Most also lack the networking skills to assist...

Sent from my XT1254 using Tapatalk 2

My girlfriend works there in tech support, and based on what she says the problem is some employees just push crap into another department because they dont want to deal with it, and then other departments aren't allowed to handle it due to ridiculous Comcast rules. She has actually been old by supervisors many times NOT to fix something she could resolve because that isnt what shes there to do.
 
Back
Top