Snow clearing - best option (vehicle plow / farm tractor / garden tractor)

Atrus

Forum Member
As we're creeping into summer and 90* temps, I'm already thinking ahead to next winter...not really sure which way to go. Money is definitely a consideration. I recently moved into a house in the country, with a 300' gravel drive. I also have a good buddy 2 miles away with a lengthy gravel drive, and my parents are 15 mins away have a fairly large concrete drive.

Option 1 - I have a 2003 Yukon that's a spare vehicle. Runs great, was in a wreck and has a salvage title, so I just hang onto it 'cause why not. Is it feasible to find a decent cheap "consumer grade" plow and use that on this thing in the winter? The idea of clearing snow with the radio on, a coffee in the cupholder, and the asswarmers on is very attractive. It also gives me the option of helping out my parents and/or buddy if they need it. Concerns are how well the vehicle can handle light plow duty, and moreso, what the cost would be. I have no idea on what kind of setup would work best and if it'd be cost effective.

Option 2 - I was considering picking up an old Ford 8N with a backblade. I could probably get the pair for $2k or so. The tractor would come in handy from time-to-time as I have a few acres of land, but really, it'd sit 99.9% of the time and really just get used for snow duty. Said buddy also has an 8N that I can borrow should I need one for actual tractor duties. I'd also be limited to plowing only my driveway (no helping buddies/parents). I also question how effective snow removal with the back blade would be. I used one to do light grading of the dirt in my yard, so I have a little glimpse of how it'd perform.

Option 3 - I also have a decent lawn tractor....2010 Craftsman (Husqvarna) YTS4500. It's a beefier consumer grade tractor. 26hp Kohler twin, 54" deck. I could pick up a plow or snowblower attachment for that. Again, I'd be limited to only doing my driveway. Seems opinions on a plow are both positive and negative. Snowblower attachment seems to get really good reviews.

Any experience/thoughts? I'd love to have an old 8N, just because they are cool. On the other hand, I'd also love to be able to comfortably and warmly clear the snow quickly. I'd also like to be cheap, and it seems leveraging the lawn tractor may be the cheapest route of the 3 as a brand new snowthrower for it is like $1400 - may be able to find something used for cheaper.
 
Option 3 would be a no go for me. I would consider buying a Polaris Ranger or RZR with a plow before a lawn tractor.

Realistically Option 1 is the best and could provide extra income if needed.
 
Anyone have experience with one of those rear "hitch mount" plows? Maybe that's a viable option for a LD full size SUV?
 
I too live out in the country....way out in the country.

I also have 300' of driveway. I hand shovel my driveway.
I consider it my winter workout! It is very common to have
3 to 4 foot snow drifts, several years ago we had 5' drifts!
(those I don't hand shovel!)

Since you already the Yukon, to me its no question, purchase
a used plow, so my vote is Option 1, you'll be the most comfortable
and it could be one of the cheaper options as well. That is what I'd do.




Snowday 1 -1 .jpg
 
I had a house and 15 acres right where the Chrysler tech center is off Squirrel Rd. They bought me out in 1988. I had about a 300' gravel drive I used to cut about 5 acres with my 8N Jubilee tractor and I also had a 4WD pick-up. I put a Western plow on the truck and plowed the snow with it. I also had both options open to me at the time, but I would still do exactly the same thing.

Just my .02....grr
 
Get a 4wd quad and ad a plow. Then enjoy it in the summer as we’ll .

Best Option in my opinion.

I currently clear our 200' driveway with a late 90s craftsman lawn tractor with a 48" blade. It does a good job but takes quite a while. Doesn't have the most balls either so if its more then around 4" I can only push downhill not up. I added knobby tires and about 100lbs of weight which helped but not be all end all. Also cant really push back the piles once we get multiple snowfalls which can be a pain.
 
ECF3071F-2419-4DE0-83FA-210DE0E66023.jpegAt my old house in Detroit I had a 200’ drive and a Honda four traxx with a plow. Worked great and the plow comes off real easy for transport or season change.
 
Last edited:
And I would also use it to spread dirt and rocks and grade the drive way lol. Just had to chain the top so it didn’t pivot.
 
+1 on the quad + blade, but Yukon would be a cheaper and probably heavier duty option. A full sized utility quad or SxS that's reliable is going to run you a couple K easily, then add the blade.

The nice part about the quad is you could use it year round.
 
Thanks for the input, guys. Didn't realize the quads did that well!

Yeah, seems like that'd be the most expensive option. I've started looking at some of those backblades for the Yukon. Seems like that could be a decent option.
 
Plow on the truck is only the way to go.... atv's and snow blowers are crap with heavy snow... you want something that will move 12"+ and you want something you don't have to dress for. Ive had jeeps, snow blowers, lawn mowers with plows, bobcat (I still use at work).... 1500 should get you something used that's functional... with a plow you will have no worries and it will be much faster to complete the job.... and 5 years from not there will still be a market for the plow.
 
I've been rocking a John Deere garden tractor with a plow. I can cut grass, pick up leaves, and plow with just one piece of equipment.

Only down fall is it really wouldnt be easy to do anyones driveway who isnt close to you.
 
I prefer option 4, which would be to move south, like I did...lol. If that’s off the table, option 1 seems to be the best.

Dennis
 
45708991484_9b16a61873_b.jpg


We use a tiller on the back in the summer, as well as forks on the bucket to unload pallets from trucks. (New Holland Boomer 25)
 
I have a Bolens garden tractor (1800 Eliminator, to be precise) that I use to plow 330' of driveway, two turnarounds, and a large parking pad... and once in a while the trails.

I used to use a 1 ton Chevy with an 8.5' commercial plow on it.

I'd consider putting a light blade on a Jeep CJ/YJ/TJ.

The Bolens works well because it has foot controls for forward/reverse. I have trencher tires on it so it doesn't need chains. It hauls ass at about 11mph in forward and 9mph in reverse. The forward/reverse foot controls your hands free for the blade and steering. Direction changes are fluid. You can see what you are plowing and you can make on-the-fly adjustments to ensure you don't peel grass and whatnot.

It does suck when there is a lot of snow (more than 6") because then I have to stack it. Which takes longer.

It takes about 15 minutes to do the whole driveway area, sometimes longer depending on the furrow at the end of the driveway (I live in the outside bend of a road). If there is a lot of wet snow (6"+) it takes about an hour.

My neighbors all use random items. Some use ATVs, one uses a Kubota subcompact, an oldtimer uses an antique Ford (Jubilee maybe?), one uses an old Massey 2135, two use blowers, and another guy uses an old Dakota. The only one faster than me is the guy with the Dakota, and only when there is a lot of snow. The guys with the blowers and myself are the only ones that don't do assloads of raking and lawn repair in the spring.
 
I have a plow truck for our 762' driveway (93 diesel dually with 7.5' western plow). That is literally the only use for the truck for us. I should probably fix it up and actually drive it but that takes time & $$ which I just don't have these days.

If you do put the plow on the front of the Yukon, keep an eye on the suspension parts. The extra weight will wear out your bushings, etc a lot faster. But it is nice plowing from inside. I currently shovel near the house and then switch to the truck to plow the length and clear by the road. Usually need to take off the hat & gloves as it's warmer in the truck. :lol:
 
I'm with wrath on this one. I have a 77 John Deere 400 super tractor with a 54" 4 way plow. I push really fast too. Do not dismiss a old garden tractor. My 400 weighs in just under 2000 lbs (beet juice in tires, and 300lbs of steel weight on the 3 point and with me on it)when I'm plowing and even wet snow won't slow me down. Best part is, I have under $2000 into it, and have a 60" deck for the summer time mowing.
 
Back
Top